Mickey Mantle's Steakhouse

Recommends

nedb7

Joined 8 years ago

Very good, not great. I went and had the caesar and a ribeye. Salad was very good, steak was pretty good. Nice atmosphere. Bartender was excellent.

Auditman,(another reviewer) you need to realize, red wine is served at room temperature, not chilled.

Doesn't Recommend

feliciaallgood

Joined 7 years ago

Not worth your time or money!!. We rarely choose to spend a lot of money for a dinner out. Usually try to keep it to about $30 for two. We chose Mickey Mantle's Steakhouse for a holiday occasion and were sorely disappointed. When you order steak for $25, it would have been nice to have a potato or at least some steamed veggies. Nothing but the steak on the plate and it was chewy. My husband didn't even finish it. I had pasta with shrimp (4 shrimp). We will never go again. By the time we paid the tip, it was $68 for one steak, one salad and a plate of pasta with four shrimp. Total waste of the evening out. Would have liked to ask for my money back but didn't want to make a scene.

Recommends

rojo296

Joined 7 years ago

Fantastic staff & even better food. The staff were fantastic! The waiter was very professional, knew the menu & answered all questions, even suggesting splitting the side dishes (family style). His wine suggestion was also dead on, a great reisling. The rest of the staff were very unobtrusive but immediately at the table to refill glasses, clear dishes or answer any questions.

The food was definitely first rate. The very tender filets were cooked perfectly, including my sister-in-law's "slightly less than medium". The lobster tails were HUGE yet tender, obviously fresh, & done to perfection.

The location is prime also. Across the street from the ballpark, right on the canal. They have valet parking which is a blessing in Bricktown. Just pull up to the door, enjoy a beautifully prepared meal, take a stroll along the canal afterward, then pick up your car right at the door.

This is an expensive restaurant, but you get what you pay for. Mickey Mantel's rates right up there with Morton's & the others listed by previous reviews. If you don't want to pay the price for the quality of USDA Prime beef, go to Sirloin Stockade. If the lobster or crab is out of your league, go to Red Lobster. Quality is not cheap. Mickey Mantel's is now my favorite local chop house.

Recommends

dktrpepr

Joined 8 years ago

My Only Stop In OKC and Mickey Mantle's Put It Out of the Park. I was in town on business staying one night in OKC and was in the mood for steak. Great recommendation by a local who mentioned Mickey Mantle's Steakhouse. Traveling on business has taken me far and wide with plenty of celebrity restaurants, but Mantle's is among the best when it comes to steak. The filet was a perfect cut, welll prepared with sides to match that were simply mouth watering. An extensive wine list was expected and again Mantle's came to the plate.

Another reviewer compared Mantle's to Ruth Chris or Morton's, which is understandable as they are steakhouses. However, with a great location on the canal and accross from the ballpark, this steakhouse has more to offer than just great steaks. A guest oriented staff eager to please its patrons with great service, you can't miss this place for a great evening out in Bricktown.

This only reason my rating doesn't get a 10 as that steakhouse rating has gone to Del Frisco's in Denver. Look them up!

Recommends

okpackerfan

Joined 7 years ago

Fan freakin tastic. This is the place for steaks in OKC. It seems pricey for some locals, but if you have been to a Morton's, Ruths Chris, or Del Frisco, it is about the same cost. The wine list is great, the steaks are fantastic, and the decor is what you would expect of a top-notch room. The filet was melt in your mouth tender and cooked to perfection. The service is of course impeccable and being in the heart of bricktown, it is a great place to start or finish an evening out.

Recommends

Jenniferhammonsdc

Joined 10 years ago

Yum. The food and service is truly top notch, but you pay for it! Wonderful food, service, location, and ambience!

Recommends

auditman

Joined 10 years ago

Chill out!. Food was excellent, but what's up with the NYC prices? Waiter was terrific. Two bottles of red wine were at a warm room temperature and needed a slight chilling. Don't they have a wine cellar for such a great list?

Recommends

okie4horns

Joined 11 years ago

Check out the Rib-Eye!. Great place. Excellent atmosphere! Great service

and food. I reccomend the rib-eye. I was suprised with the wine selection. A must try location! Everything from the salad to desert was great!