Mickey Mantle's Steakhouse

06/18/07

Very enjoyable evening

by nrf76

My husband and I had dinner at Mickey Mantle's for our anniversary and it was truly a memorable evening. Everything we ate: appetizers, salads, entrees and sides were delicious. The service was impeccable. We had one slight problem, our ala carte sides were not delivered with our meal, we explained this to the server and the sides were promptly brought (1-2 minutes tops). This seemed to bother the management and staff more than it did us, as we were offered many apologies as well as free dessert and the items were comped, none of which we requested. Yes the meal was pricey, more than most okies expect to pay, but for the top notch food and excellent service, we didn't mind.

04/04/07

Something else to be desired...

by scooby06

My wife and I went here for Valentines Day last year and were sorely disappointed. We chalked it up to the special menu and the numerous diners that night, and thought we would give it another shot for my birthday this year. Again, disappointment. The lobster tail had small pieces of the shell that we had to pick out, and the flavor of the filter mignon steak was marginal at best. We also opted for the mesquite cold smoked asparagus that night, a chef's special. The smoked flavor was overwhelming. At first I thought the steaks had been burnt, but soon realized it was only the asparagus. For a total price tag of $175, of which only 20% was a bottle of wine, much better food can be had around the city for a lot less money.

11/01/06

Very good, not great

by nedb7

I went and had the caesar and a ribeye. Salad was very good, steak was pretty good. Nice atmosphere. Bartender was excellent.

Auditman,(another reviewer) you need to realize, red wine is served at room temperature, not chilled.

• Pros: good bartender